Long Beach Island Appreciation Over the Years
The average LBI sale price has risen 158% since 2016. Here’s what the numbers show and what they mean for buyers and sellers today
Last updated: November 2026
The last 10 years on LBI
Year by Year
2016: $978,742
2017: $1,075,976 (+9.9%)
2018: $1,100,766 (+2.3%)
2019: $1,140,055 (+3.6%)
2020: $1,288,948 (+13.1%)
2021: $1,559,680 (+21.0%)
2022: $1,872,899 (+20.1%)
2023: $2,043,580 (+9.1%)
2024: $2,263,518 (+10.8%)
2025: $2,393,980 (+5.8%)
2026: $2,527,173 (+5.6%, year to date)
Total, 2016 to 2026: +158.2%
What Drove It
2016 to 2019: Steady growth. Prices rose about 16% over three years. LBI was a healthy market, but not a dramatic one.
2020 to 2022: The surge. Remote work and demand for second homes pushed prices up 64% in three years. 2021 alone was up 21%.
2023 to today: Holding strong. Many people expected a pullback. Instead, prices have kept climbing about 8% a year. A few things kept the market strong:
Inventory kept shrinking. LBI used to have 300 to 500 homes for sale at any given time. In 2025 that number fell into the 120s.
Buyers from North Jersey and New York kept coming to the island.
Older homes were torn down and rebuilt. Larger, elevated new construction is replacing older cottages, which raises what the typical LBI sale looks like.
Rental income keeps LBI attractive to buyers who want a home that helps pay for itself.
Where the Market Is Today
Prices are still going up, but at a slower and steadier pace than 2021 and 2022. Inventory remains tight, so well-priced homes are still in demand.
For sellers, your home is likely worth much more than when you bought it, and buyers have few options to choose from.
For buyers, LBI has ten straight years of rising prices and a limited supply of land. It has a long track record of holding its value.
What’s Next: Elevation and Building Code
Flood elevation requirements are a growing factor on LBI. We expect that over time, homes with three usable floors will become more valuable. Once new rules make it more difficult to fit a ground floor above base flood elevation, many new builds will lose that level, and existing homes that already have it will be harder to replace.
Let’s Talk About Your Home
Want to know how these numbers apply to a specific property or street? Contact Matt Cappo at The Van Dyk Group.
📞 (609) 496-1423 | ✉️ mcappo@vandykgroup.com
Source: Bright MLS. Average sale price of single-family and duplex properties across all of Long Beach Island. Condos are not included. 2026 figures are year to date as of November 2026. Average sale price reflects all sales in a given year and is not the change in value of any one home. Past performance does not guarantee future results.