Long Beach Island September real estate market recap

Large open floor plan of a beach house on Long Beach Island overlooking the barnegat bay

Long Beach Island (LBI) September real estate market recap

The LBI real estate market saw significant activity throughout September! While there were less total listings in September compared to August this is common due to September being a common time to close on a property. There was a healthy mix of new listings, properties under contract, pending, and closed sales. There is enough data recorded within a month to give a good snapshot of the direction the market is headed and how it has evolved over the last few months. Whether youโ€™re tracking the strength of the market, pricing or inventory trends, or just want to stay updated on everything LBI these updates offer valuable insights into dynamics we are seeing in the Long Beach Island real estate market.

By: Matt Cappo LBI Real Estate Agent | The Van Dyk Group ๐Ÿ“ฑ Cell: 609-496-1423 โ˜Ž๏ธ Office: 609-492-1511

โœ‰๏ธ mcappo@vandykgroup.com ๐ŸŒ www.LBILiving.com

Key stats

graph highlighting the average sales prices on Long Beach Island NJ

Average sale price:

  • July: $2,142,443

  • August: $2,584,268

  • September: $2,237,463

    There have been a considerable amount of transactions in the low $2Mโ€™s over the summer and into the fall signaling strong demand for properties in good condition and well located.

Line graph showing the change in sale to list price ratio for homes that sold on Long Beach Island NJ

Average sale to list price ratio:

  • July: 99.20%

  • August: 96.30%

  • September: 99.2%

Homes are selling close to 100% of the list price signaling strong buyer demand in the fall market as well as accurate pricing from sellers the past few months.

Bar graph showing the number of active listings for homes that sold on Long Beach Island NJ

Number of active listings

  • July: 191

  • August: 201

  • September: 159

Number of listings decreased due to a typical increase in September closings.

Bar graph showing the number of new listings on Long Beach Island

Number of new listings

  • July: 49

  • August: 59

  • September: 47

Bar graph showing the number of sales from July to September 2025 on Long Beach Island

Number of sales

  • July: 26

  • August: 20

  • September: 45

An increase in September sales is typical as buyers who did not want to acquire a property as a rental decided to close in the fall and let the seller collect the rental income and manage the tenants.

Line graph showing the change in average days on market for homes that sold on Long Beach Island NJ

Average days on market

  • July: 74

  • August: 101

  • September: 65

    Days on market remains historically low due to low inventory and strong demand.

Long Beach Island real estate market insights and trends

Long Beach Island saw significant activity this month with 45 home sales, and properties spent an average of 65 days on the market. The sale-to-list price ratio shows that buyer demand remains strong this fall. We also noticed last month that sellers were pricing their homes to sell, which led to quick offers at asking price. This seasonal momentum will keep sellers motivated and lead to more new activity, as we saw in late September. While the market remains competitive and well located properties get consumed quickly, buyers have the opportunity to capitalize on well priced listings ahead of the typical post fall slowdown.

For more updates on market activity or Long Beach Island in general, feel free to give me a call!

Next
Next

LBI real estate market weekly report: September 29, 2025